The Best Strategy Game Of The Year, Every Year, For 20 Years

2014 – Ultimate General: Gettysburg

Ultimate General Gettysburg screenshot of the first moments of the battle

2014 is the year when my favorite videogame of all time, Shovel Knight, came out. Yes, my favorite game isn’t a strategy game or a wargame, it’s actually a platformer, the only one I have ever enjoyed and loved ever since. This was also the time I was starting to get serious with wargaming, and one of my gateway games into what’s now a massive project in my life was Ultimate General: Gettysburg. Created by the guy responsible for the Darth Mod Total War series of mods, brilliant real-time strategy follows very closely the formula laid out by Sid Meier decades prior with his Gettysburg game. Ultimate General: Gettysburg is a game that offers an intense experience of the Battle of Gettysburg. Players command Union or Confederate forces across a series of pre-made scenarios, or by playing the whole battle. The game’s highlight is its impressive AI, which can be modified to have different personalities, offering a different experience every time you play.

2015 – Cities: Skylines

Cities Skylines screenshot of the downtop of a major city

It had been 12 years since Sim City 4 had come out, and 12 years since we had a decent city-builder title. Enter Cities: Skylines, a game that empowers players to unleash their creativity and embark on the journey of building whatever city, small village, or seaside hamlet pleases them. With one of the largest modding scenes in gaming (available through the Steam Workshop), the possibilities are endless. It also features gaming’s most realistic traffic simulation mechanics, if you’re one of those people who fail to see how that can be engaging, then it’s your time to give Cities: Skylines a whirl and test your planning mettle as you watch your vision come to life in this highly acclaimed (highly, highly acclaimed) city-building game. This was also the year that brought us The Witcher 3: The Wild Hunt, Rocket League, and Bloodborne.

2016 – XCOM 2

XCOM 2 Screenshot of Alien

Believe it or not, I’m currently on my first, full-length playthrough of XCOM 2. I have played it before, quite a lot, in fact, but never got around to finishing it, you need to realize this was the year when Battlefield 1, Overwatch, and Titanfall 2 came out, so I was rather busy, and Strategy and Wargaming was just an ink line on an old university notebook! XCOM 2, the successor to the 2012 reboot of the classic series improves the game in every aspect: there’s a new story following the defeat of the humans in the alien invasion, there’s a new and very well-implemented stealth mechanic, new unit classes, new enemy types. The War of the Chosen DLC is the cherry on top of this delicious cake by introducing new factions, new enemy heroes, new perks, new mission objectives and maps, and a lot of new mechanics like unit bonding and faction management.

2017 – Steel Division: Normandy 44

This was the year when I started Strategy and Wargaming (former OneHexAway), and Steel Division: Normandy 44 was one of my first reviews ever! You can read it here if you’d like. I called it a strange melting pot of other well-known and lesser-known strategy games. The fast-paced action, infantry-focused combat, and clean UI of Company of Heroes. The morale system a la Close Combat and the accurate historical use of WW2 hedgerow tactics can be found in Combat Mission: Normandy. The unit variety, deck building, air support, and logistics systems are imported directly from their previous Wargame series. I still stand by my review of it, and I think it has only gotten better with all the expansions it got after release.

2018 – Into The Breach

2018 was going to be a toss-up between Frostpunk and Into The Breach. Everyone’s favorite turn-based Kaiju Exterminate simulator of 2018 was a massive indie hit. Into The Breach is one of the greatest turn-based games ever made. I’ve finished its campaign several times, with nearly all available squads. You’re tasked with controlling a team of three mechs, fighting against an alien invasion and how you do it is by manipulating the location of the aliens to have them attack their own, throw them into obstacles, or outside of the map. What a fantastic experience.

Pages: 1 2 3 4

20 responses to “The Best Strategy Game Of The Year, Every Year, For 20 Years”

  1. So many hours lost to Total War!!! A great summary of the top games!

  2. Nothing tops CoH at this list. It was something else. Still holds up as an 18 years old game.

  3. nice summary, mate.

    i only played civilization from the list but it was awesome

  4. Not even a mention of Stellaris in 2016. Paradox’s best game in my opinion.

    1. Personally, I played much more HoI4 than Stellaris, which was released by Paradox less than a month after Stellaris. I would also have mentioned Victoria 2 (2010) and Victoria 3 (2022), but I suppose that I’m a sucker for Paradox games. However, I guess that their aggressive monetisation, which he mentioned when discussing EUIV, has put a damper on the company for me too, e.g. I haven’t touched EUIV in about 4 years, even though it’s still my most played game at over 3.5k hours.

  5. This list is spot on! Great website aswell.

    1. Mark Majoros-Takacs Avatar
      Mark Majoros-Takacs

      Strategy is my favourite genre. In my opinion such a list should be divided into 4 categories. RTS, TBS, Tactical Strategy and Business Strategy. They all play very differently and I would put Warcraft-Starcraft series, Civ series, X-Com series and Railroad Tycoon series on the top respectively, even if my favourite might differ. With honourable mentions of the Total War series and Crusader Kings series as they are fantastic and of special breed. There are some nice entries that you have mentioned and some of them are indeed among my favourites but i disagree with many of them and the articles really pissed me off. I can’t forgive that you didn’t even mention Dawn of War in 2004 and Supreme Commander in 2007, yet they made so many innovations to the RTS genre that, as JtR put it, it is HERESY that DoW didn’t win 2004. Rome TW? I love it, but it is a reskinned 3D Shogun. And Supreme Commander is probably the second best RTS after Starcraft 2. At least Rome TW has a place among the strategy giants, but you put some winner titles that I haven’t even heard of and I wouldn’t consider them strategy (hence i suggested the subcategories, in which they perhaps fit). And in the articles you are writing major releases (not startegy and neither war games) for consoles and such, I feel like this website didn’t honour it’s name.

      1. Mark Majoros-Takacs Avatar
        Mark Majoros-Takacs

        My apologies, i meant to write a comment and not a reply.

      2. Hello, Mark! Don’t be pissed off, this is just my list. I’m sure you have a different opinions and experiences! I, for example, never really loved Supreme Commander or Railroad Tycoon, but we can’t all enjoy everything. Take these lists for what they are, a place to discover new games and express our opinions, not to attack your taste or favourite games. Cheers and happy 2025!

      3. Mark Majoros-Takacs Avatar
        Mark Majoros-Takacs

        Hello Nuno, You are absolutely right. I think I got triggered as the subject is also something I feel passionate about and needed to vent, but perhaps in the end it was more of a rant, I am sorry 😉 Cheers and happy 2025 for you too!

  6. Good llist but I’m not sold on manor Lords but I’m not sure what beats it either.

  7. Great list! And I absolutely agree with your pick of Midnight Suns! Two games I would add to this are Stellaris and Civilization 5, which is the best imho.

  8. Great list! I think the only one I would change is Wargame Red Dragon instead of Gettysburg. Great job!

  9. No 2020 wasteland 3? Great game.

  10. Somehow you don’t mention the god tier Dawn of War in 2004. That’s heresy.

  11. supreme commander absolutely should have won 2007. Really the features are far too deep to even begin to mention here, but suffice to say there’s still a very active community playing this game today with fan created services to keep the game running with multiplayer and updates.

  12. That’s a great list brotha, so many hours spent on path of exile.


    1. By far the best game on the list.

  13. I do find it odd you didn’t have any of the warhammer total war games in there. I disagree with your list it hardly seems accurate.

  14. […] The Best Strategy Game Of The Year, Every Year, For 20 Years […]

Leave a Reply

Trending

Discover more from Strategy and Wargaming

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Discover more from Strategy and Wargaming

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading